hrtechoutlookeurope

Survey: Only 48.6% of Employers Think Their Job Ads Are Effective

HR Tech Outlook | Wednesday, December 06, 2023

Love it or hate it, writing a job ad is a key piece of the recruiting process. Without a captivating, well-crafted ad, attracting top candidates is nearly impossible. However, developing a job ad can be time-consuming, requiring the right blend of research, keywords, and persuasive language to convince candidates to click “apply.”

Hiring and HR professionals never seem to have enough hours in a day, and not everyone is a natural-born writer. So, how are today’s employers managing their job ad development process? Do they really know how to create a job posting? What challenges are they experiencing, and how effective do they believe their postings are in recruiting the right candidates?

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

For answers to these questions and more, we polled 216 employers from our client base who are directly involved in creating job ads for their organization. Our survey findings are as follows.

How Long Does It Take to Write a Job Ad?

First, we asked employers to estimate how long it typically takes them to write a job ad from scratch. Nearly half (47.2%) of respondents said they spend more than 30 minutes creating an ad, with 13.9% taking more than an hour. That time adds up, especially when you’re wearing multiple hats and juggling various HR and recruiting tasks.

Luckily, writing a job ad from scratch is not always necessary with the help of templates and generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools. While 67.6% of employers said they use a job posting template at least some of the time, just 10.2% use AI (like ChatGPT) to assist in creating their ads “always” or “most of the time.”

Challenges Writing a Job Ad

Finding the time to write a job ad, however, was not as big of a struggle as knowing which information to include to attract the right talent – this was the top challenge respondents cited (56.0%).

Further, 46.8% grapple with writing the ad so that it “sells” their company, and 41.7% are often unsure about which information from the job description to include in their posting.

What Information to Include in a Job Ad

Although employers were uncertain which information to include in their ad, most do comprise the most critical details: The majority of respondents said they always include candidate requirements and qualifications (78.2%), location of the job (76.4%), and benefits (63.4%).

While 56.6% always include the salary range, that percentage should be higher – as previous research has shown, listing the salary for a position increases the likelihood of a candidate applying for a job.

Job Ad Creation Best Practices

Next, we asked employers to identify the best practices they always follow when creating a new job ad. We were glad to see most employers were conscious of spelling and grammar errors – which can be a major candidate turnoff – but were surprised that less than half of review their ad for potentially biased or discriminatory language (47.2%) and research and include fair and competitive salary ranges when developing their ad (46.3%).

Job Ad Effectiveness

How effective do employers think their job ads are in attracting the right candidates? Respondents were fairly confident in their postings, as 48.6% said their ads were “very effective” or “effective.” At the same time, 42.6% said their ads were just “somewhat effective,” and only 4.2% said they were “not effective.”

Despite confidence in their ads’ efficacy, half (49.1%) of employers do not track any metrics – such as view-to-apply rates, application completion rates, and total applies – to determine how well their job ads are attracting qualified candidates.

Additionally, 46.3% of employers do not ensure their ad follows SEO best practices so the right talent finds them in search results. However, the best job postings include keywords, such as the career titles, location, and required skills a candidate may search for while on the hunt for a new position.

 
 

More in News

The dynamic and unpredictable nature of today’s business landscape has created a pressing need for improved personnel decision-making. Organizations must analyze their data to identify the root causes of challenges, apply appropriate solutions, and anticipate future developments based on concrete evidence. This approach is fundamental to effective people analytics strategies. The effectiveness of people analytics in daily decision-making is undeniable. Using people analytics, business leaders may get their CEO's attention by delving deeper into strategic HR indicators like Revenue per employee, HR effectiveness, improved hiring quality, new hire failure rate, performance turnover in key positions and diversity hires for positions that directly impact customers. As demand for workforce optimization grows, Companies in People Analytics are transforming how businesses manage human capital. Key Benefits of People Analytics: One of the most effective use cases for people analytics is turnover reduction. The influence is most obvious when an organization focuses on a certain position or group of employees. Using people analytics for targeted retention strategies can help reduce employee turnover.It can help organizations identify the sources of their most qualified candidates and determine if they are experiencing attrition within the recruitment process. This allows organizations to optimize their spending on recruiting operations and talent pipelines.  It can help identify the ideal characteristics for prospective prospects in order to maximize the recruiting investment. Companies can utilize people analytics to optimize training methods and sources. People analytics enables organizations to optimize spans and layers, reducing expenses and increasing income. Navigating the Latest Trends in People Analytics: People analytics is becoming more popular than ever. This rise is largely driven by businesses recognizing the potential of employing data insights to inform decision-making. Along with the overall trend of using data to inform business choices in all areas, senior leadership increasingly recognizes the value of people analytics. It makes logical sense: business objectives such as growth, productivity, and budget are inextricably connected to the personnel. People in charge of data analysis are responsible for identifying and explaining the metrics that are most important to executives, such as retention levels, engagement rates, and sales staffing. As people analytics becomes more widely employed in businesses, the emphasis on privacy protection grows. Organizations must guarantee that access to specific personal information is restricted to authorized personnel only. Privacy and information security demand a high level of inspection. ...Read more
Talent management is far more than just a buzzword—it reflects an organization's approach toward its employees. It can drive a transformation in how businesses view their workforce in relation to their goals and mission. The core of talent management is to identify, attract, nurture, engage, retain, and deploy the best talent available. To achieve success, they must recognize the value that top talent contributes. By cultivating talent and strategically placing individuals in the right roles at the right time, businesses can build high-performing teams and departments. Investing in such processes and strategic systems that foster employee development is crucial to create a thriving workforce. Attract premier talent: Strategic talent management allows businesses to recruit the most talented and skilled employees. It improves an organization's business performance and results by establishing an employer brand that could attract qualified candidates. Employee incentive: Strategic talent management enables organizations to motivate their employees, giving them more reasons to remain with the company and perform their duties. Continuous coverage of essential functions: Talent management equips businesses with the tasks that necessitate critical abilities to plan and address the workforce's crucial and highly specialized roles. This means that the company will have a steady stream of employees to fill essential roles, allowing it to run its operations smoothly and preventing others from being overworked, which could lead to exhaustion. Increase employee productivity: Using talent management will simplify businesses to determine which employees are best suited for a position, resulting in fewer performance management issues and complaints. It will also provide that the company's top talent remains longer. Engaged workers: Talent management enables organizations to make methodical and consistent decisions regarding their employees' development, thereby ensuring their skills' growth. In addition, when there is a fair procedure for development, employees will feel more engaged, which helps companies meet their operational needs by increasing retention rates. Retain top talent: In the long run, a company can save money on recruitment and performance management expenses if its onboarding practices result in higher levels of employee retention. Enhance business operations: Talent management enables employees to feel engaged, skilled, and motivated, allowing them to work toward the company's business objectives, increasing client satisfaction, and business performance. Greater customer satisfaction: A systematic approach to talent management implies organizational integration and consistent management philosophy. Integrating systems reduce client interaction, allowing them to meet their needs more quickly and increasing client satisfaction. ...Read more
In a data-driven hiring process, recruitment metrics are crucial. With the wide variety of metrics available, it can be challenging to identify the most effective ones. These metrics are used to assess hiring success and improve the recruitment process, enabling more informed decision-making. Time to Fill It is the total number of days in the calendar taken to recruit and hire a new employee. Time to Fill is frequently determined by counting the days between the approval of a job request and the applicant accepting an offer. The metric can be affected by several factors, including supply and demand ratios for certain positions and the efficiency of the hiring team. This metric helps in business planning by rendering information on the time required for the replacement of a departing employee. Time to Hire The period between a candidate’s application and acceptance of a job offer is referred to as the time to hire. It represents the time taken for a candidate to get from the application stage to the hiring stage. Thus, it provides insight into the performance of the recruitment team. This metric is also known as the time to accept. It always accelerates the recruitment procedures to prevent the loss of suitable candidates. Moreover, applicants do not prefer lengthy hiring processes, which will affect their experiences as well. Time to hire will be quicker if hiring for positions just requires a single interview rather than telephonic conversation, assessment, and multiple rounds of discussion. Therefore, it is essential to calculate the time to hire a new applicant. Source of Hire One of the most common recruitment metrics is tracking the sources that attract recruits to a company. This measurement helps in monitoring the efficiency of various recruitment channels. Job boards, a company's career page, social media accounts, and sourcing agencies are a few examples of recruitment sources. Therefore, it is better to have an understanding of the channel that most of the successful candidates come from. First-year Attrition First-year Attrition, or new hire turnover, is another crucial recruiting metric essential for successful hiring. Candidates who leave in the first year on the job fail to become completely productive and usually cost a lot of money to the company. First-year attrition can be managed and unmanaged. Managed attrition occurs when the employer terminates the contract, whereas unmanaged attrition occurs when the candidate departs on their own. Managed attrition indicates a bad first-year performance or a bad fit with the team. Unmanaged attrition is a result of unrealistic expectations, which compel a candidate to quit. Quality of Hire It is a measure of a candidate’s performance, which indicates their first-year performance. High-performance ratings are an indication of successful hiring, whereas low first-year performance signifies bad hires. Quality of hire is required to calculate Success Ratio which is important to understand recruitment utility analysis. This analysis helps the company calculate the return on investment for different selection instruments. ...Read more
Executive search has entered a period of structural strain. Boards and executive teams face a narrowing margin for error as leadership transitions unfold against volatile markets, compressed innovation cycles and rising expectations for adaptability. Traditional search models, built largely on retrospective credentials and pattern matching, struggle to predict whether an executive can perform under unfamiliar pressure or evolve in response to shifting strategic demands. For buyers evaluating an Executive Search Firm Company of the Year, the question is no longer about reach or reputation alone, but about how effectively a firm reduces leadership risk over time. A credible standard in this category emerges from three intertwined capabilities. The first is a forwardlooking assessment. Modern executive appointments demand insight into how leaders think, learn and recalibrate when conditions change, not just how they have performed in stable environments. Firms that can demonstrate cognitive flexibility, decision-making under stress, and long-term learning capacity provide buyers with a materially stronger signal than résumé-driven evaluation. The second capability is contextual intelligence. Executive performance varies widely by industry, geography and regulatory environment. A firm that understands how leadership expectations shift across global, regional and local scopes offers clients a more accurate fit between role complexity and executive capacity. This becomes especially critical as organizations operate across borders, integrate advanced technologies, and manage supply chains spanning multiple risk profiles. The third capability is continuity beyond placement. Executive failure often stems from misalignment in the first year, not from a lack of talent. Firms that treat search as a transaction miss the opportunity to protect retention, accelerate productivity and surface early warning indicators. Buyers increasingly value partners that remain engaged through onboarding and integration, helping organizations translate selection decisions into durable leadership outcomes. Top Notch Finders reflects these criteria with unusual consistency. Its approach moves away from backwardlooking executive screening toward predictive assessment rooted in cognitive and behavioral indicators. Rather than isolating decision-making skills in abstract testing environments, it evaluates how leaders function under pressure, manage competing demands and adapt when information is incomplete. This perspective allows it to surface executives capable of sustaining performance through uncertainty, not merely navigating known scenarios. Industry context further differentiates its work. The firm demonstrates deep familiarity with complex sectors such as aerospace, manufacturing, semiconductors and cross-border operations between the United States and Mexico. That experience informs how it calibrates leadership profiles to real operating constraints, including regulatory load, supply chain volatility and talent scarcity. Instead of forcing uniform criteria across assignments, it adjusts the evaluation to the specific complexity of each mandate. Its engagement model also extends beyond the hire. By integrating onboarding support and retention-focused analytics, it helps clients stabilize leadership transitions and reduce costly executive turnover. This continuity reframes executive search as a strategic partnership focused on long-term leadership resilience rather than short-term placement success. For buyers seeking an Executive Search Firm Company of the Year, Top Notch Finders stands out as a measured, future-oriented choice. It aligns predictive assessment, contextual understanding and post-placement continuity into a coherent model that directly addresses the risks executives face today. In a category where precision increasingly outweighs scale, it represents a disciplined standard for organizations that cannot afford leadership missteps. ...Read more